Are Farmers Markets Cheaper?
Getting the best value out of everything is part of human nature, so it is not surprising that this also applies to fresh farm produce. Farmer markets continue to gain more popularity in the United States and many other parts of the world as more people turn towards organic foods. But consumers often question if farmer markets offer the best value for their purchases, especially when compared to other fresh food outlets like; supermarkets, retail markets, or the good old grocery stores.
This article fundamentally focuses on which option (farmer markets or other fresh food outlets) is more economical for consumers, so here are some answers to some frequently asked questions concerning farmers markets.
In many cases, farmers markets are cheaper than other stores, especially for seasonal fruits and vegetables. It is also possible to find competitive prices for meat at local farmers markets by direct buying with no middleman. However many supermarkets and big retailers are able to lower the prices by buying in large quantities.
Are farmers markets cheaper than grocery stores?
Farmer markets are the first-choice destination for consumers who desire fresh farm produce. While the food here is usually more organic when compared to the grocery stores, it also offers the benefit of being less expensive –on average. This is mainly because the grocery stores have to cover transportation costs, storage, and sometimes make up for the spoilt food produce
Although it is most often associated with organic fresh food products than processed or canned foods. On the downside, the cost and availability of fresh food products associated with farmer markets usually fluctuate with the seasons and depending on the food grown in the region. For example, in 2017, the season’s average price for tomatoes was $3.03/lbs in the farmers’ market and $1.97 per pound in grocery stores.
This is because grocery stores can import foods from abroad or other regions to cover periods of the deficit between seasons. Especially if such foods are not grown by the local farmers.
Are farmers markets cheaper than supermarkets?
Many people often use Grocery stores and supermarkets interchangeably. Although they may be similar in some ways, they differ from each other fundamentally. For starters, grocery stores are niche stores with a smaller variety of options when compared to supermarkets.
The question about who amongst the two platforms (farmers market and supermarket) offer cheaper produce is a rather tricky one without a direct answer. To put things into perspective, most supermarket chains source their produce from large scale farmers who operate locally, interstate, or abroad at relatively low prices but may later incur additional logistics and storage costs.
On the other hand, small scale farmers who sell their produce on the farmers market may not incur these charges but might need to charge a higher mark-up on their produce to make profits. A 2014 price study revealed that the prices of select food items at the farmers’ market are quite competitive with those of the supermarkets.
But note that while the prices are competitive, the qualities of both products are not the same. Foods at the farmers market are usually freshly harvested. Hence they taste better and are healthier than those obtainable at supermarkets.
Verdict: You stand to get better value for your money when you buy from the local farmers’ market as against supermarkets.
Is buying meat at farmers markets cheaper?
Meat is an essential commodity for many consumers, especially in the U.S. Data from the North American Meat Institute revealed that American companies produced 100 billion pounds of meat products in 2017.
Comparing meat prices in farmer markets directly with other platforms is complicated due to the non-linear nature of the meat industry. For instance, big meat companies in the U.S in a bid to lower operating costs, make use of non-organic practices — applying antibiotics and hormones — when raising their animals.
On the other hand, it is more common to find local farmers at the farmers market adopting more sustainable and environmentally friendly practices to grow their animals.
A direct price comparison shows data of the meat prices gotten from farmers markets in the state of Virginia in 2019 were $6.83, $4.96, $7.24 per pound for ground beef, whole chicken, and pork chop sequentially.
The average price of the same products from supermarket chains cost $5.5, $3, and $8 per pound, which means meat produce from farmers market are usually more expensive but more healthy to consume.
Verdict: While data available for meat products indicates that buying from farmers may not be as economical as other platforms, consumers stand the advantage of knowing where and how they raise the products they consume.
Are farmers markets cheaper than Wholefood?
Wholefood basically stands for unprocessed foods. They are used to refer to foods that have undergone very little to no processing at all. It is ideal for people looking to maintain a healthier diet by staying away from the junk used to preserve fresh food produce.
Hence, several whole food stores are springing up within and outside of the United States. In a way, we can also classify fresh farm products found in the farmers’ market as Wholefood because they are usually in their natural state.
The price difference only comes into play when retail outlets attempt to push these products on their platforms. Whenever this happens, it is not surprising to find Wholefoods on these platforms selling at a higher price than at farmers markets because of the marketing hype and packaging that retail associate with these products.
Verdict: Farmers markets are usually less expensive than Wholefood due to the marketing hype retail outlets often associate with these types of food products.
Are farmers markets cheaper than online shopping?
Farmers markets are no longer restricted to physical locations as they are also witnessing the trend of going digital in an attempt to reach more customers, especially with the pandemic raging on. While online shopping has its perks of convenience and home delivery, exorbitant delivery and membership fees add to the overall cost of purchasing fresh food products.
With that in mind, a comparison between physical farmers markets and online shopping platforms of grocery and supermarket chains yields some fascinating results. According to a 2017 survey on produce prices in Santa Monica farmers market in California, found food prices (mostly vegetables and fruits) to be cheaper than that of Whole Foods supermarket chain in the same area.
Factor in the cost of delivery from the produce warehouse, other membership and registration fees, and the likes. Coupled with the fact that no form of negotiations is possible on online platforms compared with what you get at a farmers market, we are bound to see a significant price difference between physical farmers’ markets and online food shopping platforms.
Verdict: Farmers markets offer some very competitive pricing depending on seasonality and other factors than online shopping platforms.
Are farmers markets cheaper than retail markets?
Retail outlets still serve as the foundation that supports commerce all around the world. They comprise supermarkets, discount stores, warehouse stores, and a host of others and are decentralized. In addition, they are found almost everywhere in the community.
How the prices of retail outlets compare with farmers market is a bit complex. But for starters, it is possible to find small-scale local farmers some of the smaller retail outlets who later charge higher prices for fresh produce.
For larger retail outlets, where we have larger-scale farmers providing produce, and the presence of their complex supply chain infrastructure, it is easier to for these stores to sell at lower prices than farmers’ markets as they can focus on selling larger quantities.
Verdict: The answer to the above question ultimately lies in the nature of the retail outlet. While smaller retail chains may charge higher prices than most farmers markets, larger retail outlets can afford to lower their fresh produce prices.
Is it cheaper to buy vegetables at farmer’s markets?
The simple answer is yes and no. If it makes any sense? Let us put it this way, while it may be cheaper to get your vegetables from the local farmers market due to seasonality (when they are more abundant).
It would most likely be more expensive to get the same items during the off-season from the local farmers markets than other retail outlets that can directly import from regions that produce them in abundance at the current season.
Also, retail outlets can readily receive supply from larger-scale farmers who can employ the economies of scale in their operations and thus sell at a lower price.
Verdict: The cost of vegetables in farmer markets depends on a whole lot of factors. Sometimes it could be cheaper, other times it is more expensive.
Is buying fruits at farmers markets cheaper?
Just like in the case of vegetables, the same applies to fruits. Seasonality is often a very crucial factor as plants do not produce fruits all-year-round. Buying fruits from the farmers market tend to be of better value as they are usually fresher and not preserved by refrigeration and chemicals.
You also get access to a more diverse variety of fruits that you often would not find off the shelves of retail outlets. On a direct comparison basis, we can still infer data from the 2014 organic produce price survey in Nevada and Placer County. Which showed prices from farmers markets are sometimes less expensive or similar to those from grocery stores.
Verdict: It is uncommon to find prices of fruits from other retail outlets to be lower than those from farmers markets, but in those rare cases, it implies that consumers would miss out on organic, fresh, and healthy fruits
Can you haggle at farmers markets?
One advantage of farmers market is that the prices are almost always negotiable, which is contrary to grocery stores, supermarkets, and online stores where all the commodities are at a fixed price. Since there are many farmers with their different stands, you have the freedom to scout stands and haggle for products until you get a deal that is good enough for you.
It helps build a healthy relationship with some of the farmers, and with more familiarity, some of them sell their products at a good discount. While haggling seems stressful to some. Plus, it is an excellent opportunity to ask farmers questions about the produce.
List of food that is cheaper in farmers markets
Now that we have established that specific food items are cheaper in some farmer markets, while others are more expensive, below is a list of products that are usually cheaper in farmers’ market than most retail platforms;
- Vegetables: If there is one thing you are assured of getting at a less expensive price and a superior quality, it is vegetables. These are usually fresh and free from additives, but also dependent on the season and locality. Some of these vegetables include cucumbers, cabbage, green bell peppers, etc.
- Fruits and berries
- Herbs and spice: Like; turmeric, garlic, etc.
- Others (Organically produced eggs, milk cheese, etc.)
What is the final verdict?
Several factors — season, locality, and, yes, haggling skills — affect the prices of food products in the local farmer markets, but these factors may not necessarily apply to other platforms. Because these factors change on a cyclical basis, sometimes it is cheaper to purchase foods at the farmers market, and other times, it is cheaper to do so in the other outlets.
Notwithstanding (in spite of) these factors, there are many other benefits that come with buying food at farmers markets. These benefits include the fact that the foods are healthier, fresher, and more delicious than items from grocery stores or supermarkets. Also, buying from farmers helps grow the local economy.